In the present work, we have prepared ternary mixtures by incorporating different fractions of the LiTFSI salt into the PYR13TFSI-PYR13FSI blend, having care to keep the overall TFSI:FSI mole ratio = 2:3. The physicochemical and electrochemical properties of the resulting LiTFSI-PYR13TFSI-PYR13FSI electrolytes were studied. Finally, preliminary battery tests with NMC cathodes and graphite anodes were performed.
Results and Discussion
The aqueous procedure route allowed to synthesize high purity (Li+ and Br− content below 2 ppm), anhydrous, clear, colorless and odorless ionic liquid samples with yields ranging from 85 to 90 mol.%. Ternary electrolyte mixtures with water content below 2 ppm were prepared.
Figure 1 summarizes the physicochemical characteristics of PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI binary blends,
9 prepared in order to synergically combining two different ionic liquids. The results, coming from previous investigation,
9 show how at low temperatures (≤ −20°C) proper formulations of the ionic liquid mixtures exhibit extremely higher conductivity values with respect to the single materials which, conversely, are in the solid state (PYR
13TFSI and PYR
13FSI melt at 12 and −9°C, respectively).
2 This behavior, in good agreement with the DSC results previously reported,
9 is due to the different steric hindrance of the TFSI and FSI anions, which hinders the crystallizatiaon of the ionic liquid mixtures.
2,9 Nevertheless, above 0°C, e.g., where the mixtures as well as the single ILs are in the molten state, the ion conduction is seen to increase with increasing the content of the more conductive ionic liquid (PYR
13FSI). The FSI mole fraction was chosen equal to 0.6 as the right compromise among fast ion transport properties even at low temperatures, electrochemical/thermal stability, good film-forming ability and cost (FSI is rather expensive). This corresponds to a FSI/TFSI mole ratio equal to 3:2. Therefore, the (
x)LiTFSI-(
y)PYR
13TFSI-(1-
x-y)PYR
13FSI (where
x,
y and (1-
x-y) represent the mole fraction of the single components, respectively) ternary ionic liquid mixtures were prepared having care to keep the overall FSI mole fraction (1-
x-y) equal to 0.6. The LiTFSI mole fraction was ranged from 0 to 0.2, corresponding to a molar concentration from 0 M to 1.12 M.
Figure 1.
Density (panel A), ionic conductivity (panel B) and viscosity (panel C) vs. FSI mole fraction dependence of PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI binary ionic liquid mixtures at 20°C. The conductivity data are reported also at −20°C. The error bars fall within the data markers. Data from reference
9.
The ternary electrolytes were subjected to impedance measurements aiming to determinate the ionic conductivity behavior. As example,
Figure 2 illustrates selected AC plots obtained at various temperatures during the heating scans carried out on the 0.1LiTFSI-0.3PYR
13TFSI-0.6PYR
13FSI sample. At low temperatures (−30°C), the IL mixture exhibits the typical impedance response of an electrolyte sandwiched between two quasi-blocking electrodes.
15 A high frequency (100–1 kHz) semicircle is observed (falling into the origin of the axes), which was seen to be associated to two different contributes, i.e., bulk and grain boundary electrolyte resistance
15 as confirmed by the analysis of the AC measurements, suggesting the presence of heterogeneous phases within the IL sample. At lower frequencies (<1 kHz), an inclined straight line toward the real axes (Z’), typical of the blocking electrode capacitive behavior,
15 is displayed. At slightly higher temperatures (from −30 to −25°C), the semicircle is remarkably reduces (poorly visible in panel A) and shifted to higher frequencies due to the electrolyte resistance decrease with the temperature raise.
15 It is interesting to note that the response feature change in passing from −30 to −25°C (e.g., progressively disappearance of the semicircle) indicates minimization of the grain boundary contribution and increase in ionic conductivity. At −20°C (panel B) just an inclined straight-line, whose intercept with the real axes gives the IL electrolyte sample ionic resistance,
15 is seen in the AC plots. Further increase in temperature (>−20°C) results in progressive shift of the high frequency intercept toward lower resistance values and no spectrum shape change was noticed up to 100°C.
Figure 2.
Impedance plots taken on a symmetrical Pt/0.1LiTFSI-0.3PYR13TFSI-0.6PYR13FSI/Pt cell at selected temperatures. Frequency range: 65 kHz – 1 Hz. Panel A: from −30 to −25°C. Panel B: from −20 to 50°C. The equivalent circuit models using for fitting the AC responses are reported as inserts in panels A and B.
The analysis of the impedance responses was performed defining an equivalent circuit model taking into account all possible contributes to the impedance of the electrolyte under test.
15 The validity of the chosen circuit was confirmed by fitting the AC responses using a Non-Linear Least-Square (NLLSQ) software developed by Boukamp;
16,17 only fits characterized by a χ
2 factor
16,17 lower than 10
−4 were considerable acceptable. The general equivalent circuit (see insert in
Figure 2A), proposed to represent the electrochemical cell under study (i.e., Pt / IL sample / Pt), takes into account both the bulk (R
b) and the grain boundary (R
gb) contributes to the total resistance of the IL electrolyte mixture. A constant-phase element, CPE (Q), was used in the place of pure capacitance (C). The Q
g and Q
gb (in parallel with R
b and R
gb, respectively) elements are related to the geometric and the grain boundary capacitance, respectively. Finally, the Q
dl element takes into account the double layer capacitance at electrolyte/electrode interface. Above −20°C, due to substantial modification of the shape of the AC plots, the impedance responses can be properly fitted by a simplified version of the equivalent circuit (see insert in
Figure 2B), i.e., formed by the R
b (bulk resistance) and Q
dl (double layer capacitance) elements connected in series.
The transport properties of the ternary IL mixtures were investigated in terms of conductivity vs temperature dependence as in
Figure 3. From −40 to about −25°C a linear rise from 10
−7 to above 10
−4 S cm
−1 was observed, indicating progressively enhanced ion mobility even if the samples are still in solid phase, likely due to solid-solid phase transitions. Around −25°C the conductivity vs temperature slope substantially changes, due to melting of the ionic liquid blends, in agreement with the DSC results.
9 In the molten state (>−20°C) a progressively increasing slope is displayed, typical of VTF behavior.
5–7 Around 10
−3 S cm
−1 and 10
−2 S cm
−1 are already approached at −20°C and 40°C, respectively, representing ones of the best, if not the best, ion conduction values till reported in literature for ionic liquid electrolyte mixtures.
2,18
Figure 3.
Conductivity vs. temperature dependence of (x)LiTFSI-(y)PYR13TFSI-(1-x-y)PYR13FSI ternary ionic liquid mixtures at different Li+ mole fractions. The FSI/TFSI mole ratio was kept equal to 3:2. The error bars fall within the data markers.
The addition of LiTFSI salt (regarded as replacement of pyrrolidinium cations with Li
+ones) is seen further hindering crystallization of the IL mixtures, highlighted by a shift of the conductivity behavior slope change (toward lower temperatures) with respect to the LiTFSI-free sample (in agreement with the thermal measurements).
9 This results from unfavorable ion packing ascribable to the different size of the Li
+ and (PYR
13)
+cations,
10,13 able to counterbalance the stronger cation … anion interactions (e.g., due to the higher charge surface density of the smaller Li
+ cation with respect to the PYR
13+ ones) which, conversely, lead to an increase of the melting temperature. No relevant shift of the conductivity vs temperature knee is observed with increasing the LiTFSI content (once more agreeing the DSC results),
9 suggesting that higher lithium salt concentrations do not substantially affect the melting temperature of the IL mixtures. At the same time, LiTFSI incorporation results in progressive conductivity decrease of the molten samples, ascribable to the increasing viscous drag deriving from the enhanced ion interactions,
13,19 confirmed by the rheological measurements depicted in
Figure 4. However, a bell behavior is observed at very low temperatures (≤ −25°C). At lower LiTFSI mole fractions (<0.05) the increase of the lithium salt content leads to conductivity raise (from one to two orders of magnitude) as a result of the melting temperature decrease. Conversely, at higher mole fractions (>0.05) further addition of LiTFSI results in ion conduction decay due to remarkable viscosity increase (especially at low temperatures).
Figure 4.
Viscosity (panel A) and resistivity (panel B) vs. temperature dependence of (x)LiTFSI-(y)PYR13TFSI-(1-x-y)PYR13FSI ternary ionic liquid mixtures at different Li+ mole fractions. The FSI/TFSI mole ratio was kept equal to 3:2. The error bars fall within the data markers.
Rheological measurements were performed to better understand the conduction phenomena.
Figure 4 plots the dependence of the viscosity (panel A) and resistivity (panel B, for comparison purpose) vs temperature. The measurements were run from 20 up to 80°C, e.g., where the IL mixtures show Newtonian behavior. From
Figure 4 it is clearly evident how the viscosity and resistivity (inverse of conductivity) exhibit identical behavior, e.g., a continuous decrease is observed with increasing the temperature as well as a progressive increase is seen with raising the lithium salt content, once more resulting in stronger and stronger ion interactions (due to Li
+). Therefore, the ion transport properties of the LiTFSI-PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI ternary mixtures appear well correlated with the rheological ones, i.e., the ion movement is mostly affected by the viscous drag.
20,21
The physicochemical properties of the LiTFSI-PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI electrolyte system were also investigated in terms of density at different temperatures as reported in
Figure 5. The ternary mixtures (in the molten state), exhibiting a lithium salt concentration ranging from 0 to 1.12 M, differ in density of less than 4% within the investigated temperature range (i.e., 20–90°C). A linear decrease with the temperature raise is observed, displaying identical slope not dependently on the LiTFSI content. Also, a density increase is observed with increasing the Li
+ mole fraction. Such a behavior, already detected in other IL blends,
7 might suggest structural organizational rearrangement of the cations (Li
+, PYR
13+) and anions (TFSI
−, FSI
−) within the mixtures, leading to different ion packing with increasing the lithium salt content. However, further work is required to confirm this hypothesis.
Figure 5.
Density vs. temperature dependence of (x)LiTFSI-(y)PYR13TFSI-(1-x-y)PYR13FSI ternary ionic liquid mixtures at different Li+ mole fractions. The FSI/TFSI mole ratio was fixed equal to 3:2. The error bars fall within the data markers.
A qualitative estimation of the ion dissociation of the LiTFSI-PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI mixtures was obtained by the Walden rule
22–24
Λη=k
[1]which correlates the molar conductivity (Λ) and the viscosity (η) through a temperature dependent constant (k) as reported in
Figure 6. The dotted straight line, e.g., a 0.01 N KCl aqueous solution known for being fully dissociated and having ions of equal mobility,
22 is used as the calibration curve (ideal Walden line). The LiTFSI-PYR
13FSI-PYR
13TFSI samples are seen to lie just below the ideal line of the diagram, independently on the Li
+ mole fraction and temperature. This behavior, corresponding to the most favorable conditions for ionic liquids
22 as high conductivity is combined with low viscosity, suggests that the ternary mixtures are mostly consist of independently mobile ions.
23 Therefore, the LiTFSI-PYR
13FSI-PYR
13TFSI system might be modeled as a quasi-ideal lattice, in which positive charges are almost uniformly distributed around the negative ones.
25–27 In addition, neither the Li
+ content, nor the temperature are found to affect the “
ionicity” of the LiTFSI-PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI ternary electrolyte mixtures.
Figure 6.
Walden plot of (x)LiTFSI-(y)PYR13TFSI-(1-x-y)PYR13FSI ternary ionic liquid mixtures. The dotted straight line, due to a 0.01 N KCl solution, fixes the position of the ideal Walden line.
The electrochemical stability plays a key role in defining the average operative voltage range of electrolytes in battery systems. Therefore, this crucial parameter was evaluated toward carbon working electrodes aiming to obtain more reliable results. For instance, overestimation of the electrochemical stability is generally observed in (smooth) inert electrodes (platinum, nickel, stainless steel) whereas the large surface area of carbon (rich of active sites) electrodes allows of better simulating the behavior of electrolytes in average battery systems.
Figure 7 reports the results coming from anodic and cathodic sweep voltammetries performed on selected LiTFSI-PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI mixtures at different Li
+ mole fraction. All potentials are given vs the Li/Li
+redox couple. The addition of lithium salt (blue and red traces) results in progressive increase of the current density above 4 V (not observed in the LiTFSI-free mixture), even if somewhat low values, e.g., below 30 μA cm
−2, of the residual current flow are detected up to 4.5 V. This issue was likely addressed to impurities, deriving from LiTFSI, able to catalyze the oxidation of the anions (TFSI and FSI). Repeated cyclic voltammetries (reported in panel A of
Figure 8), run on Li / 0.1LiTFSI-0.3PYR
13TFSI-0.6PYR
13FSI / carbon cells within the 3.0–5.0 V voltage range, have evidenced sharp reduction of the residual current density flow (down to just a few μA cm
−2 up to 4.5 V) even upon the first cycle. This clearly indicates irreversibility of the oxidation processes taking place during the first anodic scan in conjunction with very rapid consumption of impurities, therefore supporting for good stability of the LiTFSI-PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI electrolyte mixtures toward oxidation up to 4.5 V. It is worth to note that no corrosion phenomenon is observed in
Figure 8A, despite the TFSI and, especially, FSI anions were found to be a little bit corrosive for aluminum substrate.
28–29 However, this behavior could be related to the impurity and moisture content within the ionic liquid electrolyte (for instance, the LiTFSI-PYR
13TFSI-PYR
13FSI mixtures exhibit very low impurity and moisture content). In addition, the (working) carbon electrode may protect the Al substrate toward the ionic liquid electrolyte.
Figure 7.
Linear sweep voltammetry of selected (x)LiTFSI-(y)PYR13TFSI-(1-x-y)PYR13FSI ternary ionic liquid mixtures at 20°C. Carbon as the working electrode. Lithium as the counter and reference electrode. Scan rate: 5 mV s−1.
Figure 8.
Anodic (panel A) and cathodic (panel B) cyclic voltammetries of the (0.1)LiTFSI-(0.3)PYR13TFSI-(0.6)PYR13FSI sample at 20°C. Carbon as the working electrode. Lithium as the counter and reference electrodes. Scan rate: 1 mV s−1.
On the cathodic side (
Figure 7), two features, e.g., around 1.25 and 0.3 V vs Li/Li
+, are observed, likely ascribable to SEI formation and lithium intercalation into the carbon working electrode, respectively. The feature detected about 0.3 V, missing (as expected) in the LiTFSI-free sample (black trace), is seen to remarkably increase in passing from a lithium salt mole fraction equal to 0.05 to 0.1, resulting from intercalation of larger Li
+ amount. Below 0 V (vs Li/Li
+) massive reduction of electrolyte (mainly pyrrolidinium cation) takes place. Consecutive cyclic voltammetries (panel B of
Figure 8), once more carried out on Li / 0.1LiTFSI-0.3PYR
13TFSI-0.6PYR
13FSI / carbon cells within 0.01–2.0 V, have shown well-defined reproducible current vs voltage profiles and, therefore, the possibility to reversibly intercalate lithium cations in these ionic liquid mixture with good efficiency and without any appreciable electrolyte degradation. The disappearance of the cathodic feature around 1.3 V (vs Li/Li
+) upon the first cycle suggests establishment of suitable SEI onto the carbon working electrode (allowing reversible Li
+ intercalation process). Therefore, on the basis of the results obtained from voltammetric tests, the sample 0.1LiTFSI-0.3PYR
13TFSI-0.6PYR
13FSI is found to exhibit an average electrochemical stability window (ESW) of about 5 V, equal or wider than that of other IL electrolytes but observed in inert working electrodes.
2,18
To summarize, the incorporation of PYR
13FSI into PYR
13TFSI leads to remarkable improvement of the ion transport properties, even at low FSI mole fractions, below its melting point, indicating that properly combining ionic liquid materials hinders the crystallization of the resulting mixture. In particular, the presence of anions (as well as TFSI and FSI) displaying different steric hindrance makes difficult the ion packing through the IL mixtures, which remain in an amorphous phase even at very low temperatures. This interesting effect is due to
ionic confusion2,7–9 present in the binary mixtures, shifting the crystallization and, therefore, the melting point to much lower temperatures. Overall, IL blends allow suitably combining/tuning different properties (chemical/electrochemical/thermal stability, film-forming ability, electrode compatibility) in order to obtain ionic liquids with improved characteristics not often achievable by single materials. This allows satisfying different electrode chemistries and/or particular operating conditions. Finally, the LiTFSI mole fraction equal to 0.1 was chosen since it guarantees sufficiently high Li
+ concentration (e.g., above 0.5 M) but, at the same time, falls far with respect to the composition of the solid eutectic
13 (e.g., Li:PYR
13 mole ratio equal to 1:2).
Therefore, the formulation 0.1LiTFSI-0.3PYR
13TFSI-0.6PYR
13FSI was selected for the electrolyte to be used in Li/NMC and Li/graphite half-cells, which were subjected to preliminary cycling tests at 0.1 C and 23°C. The results, reported as voltage vs capacity profiles (referred to the initial charge/discharge cycles) in
Figure 9, show features typical of NMC
14 (blue traces) and graphite
14 (red traces) electrodes, e.g., plateaus around 4 V (NMC) and below 0.2 V (graphite), respectively, with high reversibility for the Li
+intercalation process. The plateau observed around 0.5–0.6 V in the Li/graphite first discharge supports for film-forming ability in the 0.1LiTFSI-0.3PYR
13TFSI-0.6PYR
13FSI ionic liquid electrolyte. The NMC and graphite electrodes have exhibited reversible capacity of 135 and 220 mA h g
−1, corresponding to about 87 and 60% of the value recorded in conventional alkyl carbonate-based solutions. The cycling performance, referred to preliminary charge/discharge cycles, is depicted in the insert of
Figure 9. A stable capacity value is recorded for both the electrodes, with high coulombic efficiency especially for the graphite anode. This promising behavior indicates feasibility and good compatibility of the 0.1LiTFSI-0.3PYR
13TFSI-0.6PYR
13FSI ionic liquid electrolyte with high voltage cathodes and graphite anodes. Work is in progress in our laboratories aimed to deeply investigate the behaviour of these improved LiTFSI-PYR
13FSI-PYR
13TFSI electrolyte systems with lithium battery electrodes. The results will be reported in coming soon paper.
Figure 9.
Voltage vs. capacity profiles of NMC (blue traces) and graphite (red traces) electrodes in (0.1)LiTFSI-(0.3)PYR13TFSI-(0.6)PYR13FSI ionic liquid electrolyte. Current rate: 0.1 C. Temperature: 23°C. The insert depicts the initial cycling behavior.
评论
发表评论